I liked how easy it is to apply this mascara, it does not clump and it makes my lashes look long and nice. However, I could notice significant smudging around the afternoon, giving me a more prominent racoon eye look. Probably not for me as I have oily skin, but I thought the mascara selling itself as waterproof would somewhat prevent all that from happening.

This mascara was a great find. I'm glad I gave it a try. It doesn't clump and my lashes look naturally long with this. It also lasts long and does not smudge.

I love mascaras. I almost never go out without them on my lashes so I've used different ones over the years. This one immediately went to top of my list after the first time I used it. I'm now on my second tube. Their claims are true---doesn't smudge, clump, or crumble. It fans out my lashes too and keeps them curled all day. This also won't give you spider lashes and looks more natural/subtle and clean which I like. One of the mascaras that I really like (another brand) seems to make my lashes brittle. With this one, although it might be psychological, I feel my lashes are protected thanks to the oils they put in the formula. Wand can be a little tricky to use because it's bendable and tube is very thin. Sometimes it's hard to put the wand back in. You also might accidentally put mascara on your eyelids as well during application. It takes some getting used to. I do like the bristles.