Not for REAL sweatproof & waterproof mascaras (eyeko, clinique)
well this is the only product I was disappointed. i use Eyeko sport waterproof mascara and this is the #1 waterproof and smudgeproof mascara there is since professional swimmers swore by this product, and also do I. it doesn't do the job of removing my masacara. not compact as others reviewed, still prefer the wipes type for compact. i find it too dry. it actually hurts my skin when im trying to remove my makeup, maybe not for my skin type since I have soft, thin and sensitive skin. it's not that effective for my clinique waterproof mascara also. it only does it job on drug store product mascaras that are really not waterproof and smudgeproof. (ex. maybelline, L'oreal, etc) i still go Biore over this product.
about 3 years ago