Makemania Pencil Gel Eyeliner by BCL Cosmetics

Makemania Data Pencil Gel Eyeliner

See all reviews

CLAIM TO FAME: A long-wearing gel formula that won’t run or fade, even under the hot summer sun

FAST FACTS: Smooth, richly pigmented formula; convenient twist-up packaging; glides on easily; can be used on the waterline; waterproof and smudge proof

PERFECT FOR: Creating the illusion of luscious lashes that frame your eyes

WHAT YOU GET: (1) Makemania Data Pencil Gel Eyeliner

Do not dispense too much of the product at one time. The tip may break off.

You may or may not have heard of the Beauty Creative Lab, or BCL for short, but we’re sure you’ve heard of their products. BCL is a Japanese brand responsible for some of the Asian beauty world’s most famous cult classics. Their Browlash EX, Makemania, and Tsururi lines, for example, command quite the following—and you can bet your favorite mascara there’s a good reason for all the commotion.

Write a review Share your experience with this product
Top Reviewer
Certified Buyer

Hooded eyes, meet your match!

This product is so smooth and it sets so perfectly, even though I have hooded eyes, it did not smudge or budge at all. In fact, when I swatched this on the back of my hand, it took an act of God to remove it from my skin! It will last through water, heat, sweat, tears, you name it and this baby will survive! LOVE THIS FIND SO MUCH.

10 months ago
Certified Buyer

Great for everyday

Easy, smooth application and lasts all day for me. My go-to liner for everyday wear. I use this to tightline and waterline to make my eyes pop more. It doesn't dry out as compared to the other brands I've tried. Affordable and reliable. Great for people who can't do liquid but too impatient to sharpen pencil. Highly recommended!

4 months ago
Top Reviewer

Best for tight lining

I use this Makemania Data Pencil Gel Eyeliner from BCL Cosmetics to tight line my upper eye lids and I love the effect that it gives on my eyes and on my lashes as well. I like that it adds definition to my eyes and it also makes my eye lashes appear so much fuller and thicker at the same time.

12 months ago
Top Reviewer

Lusher lashline

Aside from creating definition for my eyes, eyeliner also makes it look like I have more lashes than I actually do (huhu at my sparse lashes). This gel liner makes it easy to do so! It’s not difficult to use fill in between my lashes so I get the lush lashline look.

about 1 year ago
Top Reviewer


Very pigmented!

about 1 year ago
Certified Buyer

For the perfect smokey eye that doesn't budge!

Once this sets, it doesn't smudge! Glides on smoothly, and you can even smudge it a bit before it sets. After applying, it's best if you apply a little black eye shadow to help it set (especially on the waterline). This is best for the smokey eye look but not so good for a clean cats eye as the point is blunt.

about 1 month ago