Just so you know, we share cookies

Thanks for visiting, beautiful! BeautyMNL use cookies to ensure that we give you the best possible shopping experience. If you continue, we assume that you're happy to receive all of our cookies. At BeautyMNL, we respect your right to privacy and ensure your personal information is kept secure. Read on for our Privacy Policy

Unlimited Free Shipping until December 31, 2018

Goof Proof Brow Pencil


CLAIM TO FAME: A wedge-tip pencil that quickly defines and colors brows

FAST FACTS: Dual-ended wand features a diamond-tip pencil on one end and a spoolie brush on the other; custom non-sharpen “goof-proof” point delivers buildable soft color; glide-on waterproof formula provides 12-hour wear; built-in spoolie blends pigments and combs strands for a groomed look; Allure 2016 Best of Beauty Awards winner

PERFECT FOR: Natural-looking full brows

THIS COMES IN A MINI! Click here to see it.

Fastest and best looking
March 31, 2017
”Love that it’s: “Fast with excellent results.””
”I have seen through eyebrows. Tried everything and no matter what, it’s always a time consuming effort that doesn’t stay and looks a bit “off”. Got this one and it is the fastest best looking and easiest product for brows. Hands down.”
–T (from benefitcosmetics.com/US)\

WHAT YOU GET: (1) Goof Proof Brow Pencil

Use the wide part of the custom goof-proof tip to fill and shape brows. Build color with a couple of strokes. Use the pointed edge to define the “tail” of your brow. Blend with the spoolie brush for that “real life” brow magic.


Founded by successful models-turned-makeup artists Jean and Jane Ford, Benefit was built on the premise that “makeup doesn’t have to be serious to look good.” For the twin Fords, laughter was always the best cosmetic, a belief they infused into each of their products from the get-go. Just check out the quirky packaging and cheeky labels that accompany Benefit’s beauty boosters and you’ll get the drift! Today, the mega-brand is known for its insta-pretty solutions and ever-playful approach to beauty.

View all from this brand
Sit tight, beautiful things
are worth the wait!

25 reviews

Share your experience with this product
4.8 out of 5
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
Top Reviewer
Certified Buyer
  • Skin Type Combination
  • Skin Tone Fair
  • Facial Features Chinita
  • Age 22

First pencil

I used to never do my brows since I have naturally full brows, but learning to do my base makeup really made me curious about how I’d look with more defined brows. I hate that getting foundation on my brows made them look so washed out, so I decided to give brow pencils a go. Surprisingly, I got the hang of this after just one use and I have been using this since. I love that it makes my brows look bolder without looking too harsh, and how it lasts all day. Although it’s quite expensive, I think it’s worth it considering how long one pencil lasts me with daily use. Will definitely keep repurchasing!

about 1 month ago
Certified Buyer
  • Skin Type Oily
  • Skin Tone Fair
  • Facial Features Chinita
  • Age 27

Natural looking brows in an instant!

I’ve used a lot of eyebrow pencils out there and I can say this is THE BEST. Very easy to apply and gets the job done in half the time you use other eyebrow pencils. I got the shade medium for my fair skin and I have bleached light brown hair. The shade looks very natural. I now use this everyday. I’m saving up to buy their eyebrow mascara. The price is a little steep, but hey, it’s worth every penny.

about 2 months ago
Top Reviewer
Certified Buyer
  • Skin Type Combination
  • Skin Tone Fair
  • Facial Features Mestiza
  • Age 31

Beautiful eyebrows with this goof-proof Pencil

Eight years ago, I used Benefit's Eyebrow pencil (in medium) which I had to sharpen every now and then. So imagine my delight when Benefit came out with this baby! I use shade 04-05 because my hair is just dark brown and not jet-black. It's so easy to use and has more staying power compared to its dupes (I've tried L'oreal brow products as well). I don't have perfect salon-made brows but what I do have area beautiful everyday natural brows. This lasts long, too! This has only been my second purchase since 2016.

3 months ago
Top Reviewer
  • Skin Type Oily
  • Age 26

Favorite Eye Brow product!

I have different products from well known eyebrow brands however, this is by far the best. It is really goof proof even when I’m on the beach. Best of all it is natural and easy to apply. A little goes a long way. I love the built in spoolie. The shade #3 Medium is a good in between shades for most hair colors, in my opinion.

4 months ago
Certified Buyer
  • Skin Type Oily
  • Skin Tone Fair
  • Facial Features Chinita
  • Age 19


I have very sparse and “sabog” eyebrows, and I’ve always been loyal to my Anastasia Beverly Hills Dipbrow pomade which I used for about a year, but it takes a lot of time to perfect my brows using the pomade and it always took about 10 minutes just to fill in my brows!! So I opted to look for brow pencils instead. I was choosing over this or the ABH Brow Definer and I’m glad I chose this. The price is quite hefty, but I don’t mind splurging on my brows since they deserve it (lol) and it’s definitely worth it. My brows look more natural!!! And they look thicker for some reason. The tip of the pencil was hard for me to use, since I’m more used to using an angled brush, but after a week I got used to it and I’ve been using it everyday!!! And it stays on til the end of the day! It’s my go-to brow product!!!

7 months ago
  • Skin Type Oily
  • Skin Tone Fair
  • Facial Features Mestiza
  • Age 30

easy to use

I've been using this product for 2-3 years now. it's very easy to use. I have thick black brows and they shade they have is just perfect. it does not make make brows look too thick. just make sure you get the right shade. I also have oily skin. sometimes my makeup would just last for a couple of hours but this product stays til the end of the day.

9 months ago
12 09 promo box xtensions
Promobox lifestyle gourmet granola