Looking for the crème de la crème from our assortment? Our customers have got you covered! For this year’s edition of Customers’ Picks, we’re going through the best-reviewed basics of 2019. From MLBB lipsticks to health-boosting supplements, these are the products that any beauty and wellness junkie would be lost without. For the fourteenth installment of this year’s Customers’ Picks series, we’ve got our eyes on eye makeup. Whether you love the drama of smoky eyes and winged eyeliner or you prefer to keep it simple with fluttery doll lashes and a peachy base, there are eyeshadows, mascaras, and eyeliners for every mood, preference, and skill level.

Our customers have pretty diverse tastes themselves, and they’ve penned dozens of rave reviews for these 20 eye makeup products. So, what are you looking for? Peep the five-star options, below!

Imagic 16-Color Eyeshadow Palette, P1,150 (limited time only) Han, 20: “It’s Imagic, baby! This palette is not playing around when it comes to pigment. If you’re looking for a high-quality palette that’s very affordable, you have to get this. The shade range is awesome and everything’s easy to blend. The texture on the shimmer shades is different from the mattes. It feels like cream, while the mattes are powdery.”

Read more reviews here.

Maybelline Total Temptation Mascara Waterproof, P399 Michiko, 21: “I absolutely love this mascara, it makes my lashes look so full and volumized despite my monolids! Be careful, though, it’s really black! A little goes a long way, but it’s still buildable. This is excellent for parties, especially when put on falsies—it just gives your eyes that extra kick! It can be used for everyday too, but use only 1-2 coats.”

Read more reviews here.

L.A. Girl Gel Liner, P319 Vikki, 24: “This product is sooo amazing as an eyeliner. But you should also know that this works on brows, too! I tried to use this to fill in my sparse brows and I loved the result! It doesn’t wear off unlike other products I’ve used. It stays on the whole day no matter how sweaty you get!”

Read more reviews here.

Maybelline Lash Sensational Big Eyes Bloom Mascara, P399 Clarice, 33: “This is a great find, been using it for years. It’s a makeup bag staple for me. I put on a coat of mascara to get that fresh ‘awake’ look during the day. This mascara can transform my day to night makeup: I just apply two coats and I can achieve that doll-eyed look, which I can never go wrong with. I don’t even need to wear false lashes, since this volumizes and lengthens giving that effortless lush lashes look. You should try it, too.”

Read more reviews here.

Maybelline Volum’ Express Falsies Mascara, P499 Aurora, 35: “I’ve tried a lot of mascaras—cheap ones and even expensive ones, and all of them failed me. This one, though, has to be my go-to mascara. I wasn’t given long lashes and I have no time to go to a salon for extensions. This one [gives me that effect] and it doesn’t clump. I love it.”

Read more reviews here.

BLK Cosmetics Intense Color Liquid Eyeshadow, P299 Misty, 26: “I started upgrading my daily make-up at work around two years ago. At first I used all the ‘gifted’ eye shadow palettes we had at home, but I soon just accepted that I don’t have the hand and eye skills for applying eye shadow properly. Insert Anne Curtis’ BLK line of these liquid gems and yey! I still don’t have the skills for applying exceptional eye makeup, but the best thing about these is you don’t have to have [those skills].”

Read more reviews here.

Maybelline Volum’ Express Hypercurl Mascara, P199 Mishelle, 30: “This is definitely my favorite mascara. This is my third purchase since last year and I have no regrets. It’s affordable compared to other brands’ mascaras, but nevertheless it performs great. It creates a natural curve to my lashes that makes my eyes pop naturally. It’s great for everyday.”

Read more reviews here.

Maybelline Hypersharp Power Black Liner, P399 Gelen, 20: “I have been using this product for a month now and it’s amazing! You can control how thin or thick your cat-eye would be. This product is also long-lasting—it doesn’t wash off easily nor smudge. Would definitely buy another one once I max out the tube I have right now.”

Read more reviews here.

Maybelline The Falsies Push Up Angel Mascara (Very Black), P499 Jeannell, 25: “Been using other Maybelline mascaras for over 10 years, but this has got to be my favourite! I was a bit surprised with the wand at first since its different from the usual wands, but it allows you to reach the corners of your eyes. The ‘push up’ effect is definitely there!”

Read more reviews here.

Missha The Style 3D Mascara, P300 Sharaine, 25: “No other words to describe this mascara but perfect. It’s perfect for me, it doesn’t feel heavy on my lashes, which is what I was looking for. It doesn’t clump or leave residue on my eyelids or the area under my eyes. It curls my lashes even without a lash curler. Definitely a must-have for your kikay kit. Plus, it’s affordable too.”

Read more reviews here.

Careline Graph-Ink Liner, P170 Kris, 26: “It’s pigmented and long-lasting. It doesn’t transfer to my eyelids or smudge even after a whole day of work plus 4-hour commute OR with exercise (and I have oily eyelids). Also a good surprise: I’m a liquid eyeliner beginner and this was easy to use! The tip allows for precise application. It’s also easy to fix using micellar water and cotton.”

Read more reviews here.

L’Oreal Paris False Lash Butterfly Wings, P550 Tine, 32: “Im in love with how this product gives me the dramatic lashes I’ve always wanted. It really holds my curls the whole day. Lengthens my lashes and doesn’t smudge once applied. Cheaper than Heroine Make mascara, but gives the same effect. I like how nicely it volumizes my lashes with the asymmetric shape of the butterfly brush. I really can’t go out now without using this holy grail waterproof mascara.”

Read more reviews here.

Missha The Style 4D Mascara, P300 Danielle, 25: “It’s cheap, waterproof, it doesn’t smudge, and best of all, it doesn’t clump—AT ALL. Even if I have oily eyelids and I sweat a lot, it stays put the whole day even if I’m commuting. Most mascaras would make me look like a ghoul after a day, despite not commuting on those days. This one doesn’t melt or transfer down to my lower eyelids at all. It does flake a little bit though, hence the minus one star. So be careful to not touch your eyes, or worse, rub your eyes. The natural look is what I’m going for and this mascara helps me achieve that.”

Read more reviews here.

Maybelline Volum’ Express Magnum Big Shot Waterproof Black Mascara, P399 Hannah, 27: “You know that feeling when you find your mascara ‘soulmate’? Yep, I found this one. What I love most about this among all the hundreds of mascaras out there is that it has one of the best brushes. I how simple it is and it always helps my lashes fan out more without the ‘excess product’ dilemma.”

Read more reviews here.

Maybelline HyperSharp Liner Black, P349 Ghie, 21: “I just started learning how to apply eyeliner and was told to use the thinnest liner I could find. And this was it. The pen-like feel makes it easier to handle and the thin point helps in controlling the line. Its also lightweight and doesn’t clump when reapplying. It lasts long but make sure to avoid rubbing your eyes.”

Read more reviews here.

Wet N Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow 10-Pan Palette, P499 Rhea, 24: “If you’re looking for an affordable, on-the-go palette that will give you that ‘no makeup makeup’ look or that yas kween-of-the-night aura… well, say no more! These palettes from Wet N Wild can give you all that! It’s not just affordable, it gives you the quality you’ve been looking for. Such a work of art really! No BS here. I swear you won’t regret purchasing this.”

Read more reviews here.

L.A. Girl Eyeshadow Collection, P649 Sulperia, 33: “I bought the Nudes palette last September and it was a steal kasi sobrang mura and I loved it! The palette is so pretty and it’s great for beginners! The mattes are so nice, I just wish there were more. Yung shades na may shimmer naman is not as pigmented—you need to spray the brush para makuha yung pigments. But overall, this palette is a good buy and I love the color payoff.”

Read more reviews here.

Lioele Bubi Bubi Mascara, P200 Michelle, 26: “This probably ranks as my #1 mascara. It curls my lashes well even with just 1-3 swipes. I don’t end up with spidery, clumpy lashes but instead I end up with natural-looking, voluminous lashes. Each lash is well-defined with this mascara. The consistency is also wonderful. I get just enough product on the wand every time I take the wand out of the bottle. This mascara doesn’t clump or flake. The staying power is incredible because I can go for hours even in the Philippines’ humid weather without retouching at all.”

Read more reviews here.

Novo Cosmetics Two Tone Eyeshadow Stick, P169 (limited time only) Marjorie, 28: “I bought this because I wanted to use eyeshadow but I hate the hassle of using an applicator and dabbing it on an eyeshadow palette. I saw this, which was on sale, and more affordable than the other products. I must say, I like how easy it is to apply—you just have to do it multiple times before you get your desired color. Still, application and re-application is as easy as swiping it on your upper eyelids and you’re done.”

Read more reviews here.

BLK Cosmetics Long-Lasting Liquid Eyeliner, P299 Dona, 21: “I used this product for 2 months now and I am very impressed with it longevity. It is very handy, easy to use and the brush tip never fails to give me the precise wing that I want! The brown shade really gives your eyes the mesmerizing look and at the same time more relaxed and not as bold and strong as a black liner gives. I love this product!”

Read more reviews here.

Some reviews have been condensed for brevity and clarity.

For more cool stories and members-only perks, sign up for BeautyMNL!

Like us on Facebook.
Follow us on Instagram (@beautymnl).
Tweet us on Twitter (@beauty_MNL).
Watch us on YouTube.

The BeautyMNL App is also available for iOS and Android! For Apple devices, download it on mobile here. For Android devices, download it on mobile here. Stay tuned for updates and app-exclusive promos!